CASY
Casey's General Stores, Inc.Consumer Cyclical · $22.8B market cap
Verdict
Share price
$617.76
close of Oct 3, 2026
Fair value
$442.64
Sticker Price
Payback Price
$177.05
buy price
CASY is Overpriced: at $617.76 it trades 40% above its fair value of $442.64. Its buy price (Payback Price) is $177.05, 71% below today's price. Business quality is solid: 3 of 5 key numbers clear the 10% bar.
How we valued it
Free Cash Flow. Sales grew 5% a year over the last 3 years, below the 15% we look for in a fast grower, so we value it on its free cash flow instead of an earnings forecast.
Business quality
3 of 5 clear the 10% bar. What are the Big Five?
Follow CASY
Get notified when it reaches its buy price of $177.05. Free.
Create a free accountSuperinvestors
3 of the investors we track hold CASY. In Q2 2026, 1 added. Who we track
Mairs & Power Funds
Mairs & Power Funds · as of Q2 2026
$72.4M
91,125 shares
Torray Funds
Torray Funds · as of Q2 2026
$13.3M
16,784 shares
First Eagle Investment Management
First Eagle Investment Management · as of Q2 2026
$954K
1,200 shares
Moves in Q2 2026
Insider activity
Since Jun 15, 2026: 1 open-market purchase worth $199K, 27 sales worth $29.1M and 52 other filings (stock awards, tax withholding and similar). Why purchases matter
Purchases
Sales
Koschel Williams Ena
Chief Operating Officer · 2026-07-09
Sold
$2.3M
Bramlage Stephen P JR
Chief Financial Officer · 2026-07-08
Sold
$4.8M
Wing Allison M.
director · 2026-07-08
Sold
$444K
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$115K
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$220K
Show all 27 salesShow fewer
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$136K
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$42K
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$699K
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$515K
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$284K
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$931K
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$698K
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$1.1M
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$1.2M
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$1.9M
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$2.1M
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$1.8M
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$858K
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$712K
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$545K
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$505K
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$372K
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-07-07
Sold
$477K
Koschel Williams Ena
Chief Operating Officer · 2026-07-01
Sold
$2.4M
FRAZELL CHAD MICHAEL
Chief HR Officer · 2026-06-30
Sold
$95K
FRAZELL CHAD MICHAEL
Chief HR Officer · 2026-06-30
Sold
$2.3M
Lindsey Katrina S
Chief Legal Officer · 2026-06-29
Sold
$1.6M
Other filings
Donthi Sri
director · 2026-09-02
Award
220 shares
Donthi Sri
director · 2026-09-02
Option exercise
326 shares
Wing Allison M.
director · 2026-09-02
Award
220 shares
Wing Allison M.
director · 2026-09-02
Option exercise
326 shares
SCHMELING JUDY
director · 2026-09-02
Award
220 shares
Show all 52 other filingsShow fewer
SCHMELING JUDY
director · 2026-09-02
Option exercise
326 shares
Castanon Moats Maria
director · 2026-09-02
Award
220 shares
Castanon Moats Maria
director · 2026-09-02
Option exercise
326 shares
LENHARDT DAVID K
director · 2026-09-02
Award
220 shares
LENHARDT DAVID K
director · 2026-09-02
Option exercise
326 shares
RENDA LARREE M
director · 2026-09-02
Award
220 shares
RENDA LARREE M
director · 2026-09-02
Option exercise
326 shares
Trojan Greg
director · 2026-09-02
Award
220 shares
Trojan Greg
director · 2026-09-02
Option exercise
326 shares
Frieson Donald
director · 2026-09-02
Award
220 shares
Frieson Donald
director · 2026-09-02
Option exercise
326 shares
Spanos Mike
director · 2026-09-02
Award
220 shares
Spanos Mike
director · 2026-09-02
Option exercise
326 shares
SUTULA STANLEY J III
director · 2026-09-02
Award
220 shares
SUTULA STANLEY J III
director · 2026-09-02
Option exercise
51 shares
Heiden Cara Kay
director · 2026-09-02
Option exercise
326 shares
Lindsey Katrina S
Chief Legal Officer · 2026-06-30
G-Gift
504 shares
Lindsey Katrina S
Chief Legal Officer · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
316 shares
Lindsey Katrina S
Chief Legal Officer · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
245 shares
Lindsey Katrina S
Chief Legal Officer · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
271 shares
Lindsey Katrina S
Chief Legal Officer · 2026-06-15
Tax withholding
$2.9M
Lindsey Katrina S
Chief Legal Officer · 2026-06-15
Award
7,096 shares
Koschel Williams Ena
Chief Operating Officer · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
676 shares
Koschel Williams Ena
Chief Operating Officer · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
536 shares
Koschel Williams Ena
Chief Operating Officer · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
529 shares
Koschel Williams Ena
Chief Operating Officer · 2026-06-15
Tax withholding
$6.3M
Koschel Williams Ena
Chief Operating Officer · 2026-06-15
Award
15,206 shares
FRAZELL CHAD MICHAEL
Chief HR Officer · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
344 shares
FRAZELL CHAD MICHAEL
Chief HR Officer · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
245 shares
FRAZELL CHAD MICHAEL
Chief HR Officer · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
298 shares
FRAZELL CHAD MICHAEL
Chief HR Officer · 2026-06-15
Tax withholding
$3.1M
FRAZELL CHAD MICHAEL
Chief HR Officer · 2026-06-15
Award
7,736 shares
Brennan Thomas P JR
Chief Merch. Officer · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
411 shares
Brennan Thomas P JR
Chief Merch. Officer · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
297 shares
Brennan Thomas P JR
Chief Merch. Officer · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
318 shares
Brennan Thomas P JR
Chief Merch. Officer · 2026-06-15
Tax withholding
$3.9M
Brennan Thomas P JR
Chief Merch. Officer · 2026-06-15
Award
9,246 shares
Bramlage Stephen P JR
Chief Financial Officer · 2026-06-15
Tax withholding
$6.3M
Bramlage Stephen P JR
Chief Financial Officer · 2026-06-15
Award
15,206 shares
Bramlage Stephen P JR
Chief Financial Officer · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
676 shares
Bramlage Stephen P JR
Chief Financial Officer · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
487 shares
Bramlage Stephen P JR
Chief Financial Officer · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
492 shares
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
2,422 shares
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
1,873 shares
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-06-15
Option exercise
1,737 shares
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-06-15
Tax withholding
$22.7M
REBELEZ DARREN M
President and CEO · 2026-06-15
Award
54,486 shares
About Casey's General Stores, Inc.
Casey's General Stores, Inc. engages in the provision of management and operation of convenience stores and gasoline stations. It provides self-service gasoline, a wide selection of grocery items, and an array of freshly prepared food items. The firm offers food, beverages, tobacco products, health and beauty aids, automotive products, and other non-food items. The company was founded by Donald F. Lamberti in 1968…
Specialty Retail
Fair value and Payback Price are estimates from the company's reported financials, not investment advice. Prices as of the close of Oct 3, 2026. How the Payback Price works